Biosecurity & Prop 12 Drive Changes in Swine Facility Values
The swine industry has experienced significant shifts in recent years, evolving from a period of growth to a more cautious economic landscape. With rising costs in capital, building materials and regulatory influences like Proposition 12, swine producers in the Upper Midwest are navigating new areas, both financially and operationally.
Economic Challenges in the Swine Industry
The swine industry initially witnessed robust growth, fueled by capital availability and government incentives post-COVID-19. However, rising interest rates and skyrocketing building material costs slowed expansion. Swine appraisals now reflect a stark shift in market dynamics, with buyers and sellers considering new priorities for facilities. The characteristics of barns — such as their design, condition and compliance with new regulations — play a larger role in appraisal values today.
The Impact of Proposition 12 on the Swine Industry
A pivotal element in recent appraisals and expansion or renovation plans is the impact of Proposition 12, California’s law on animal confinement fueled by consumer-demand, which sets minimum square footage requirements for gestating sows. Producers in Compeer Financial’s territory have responded with significant investments in facility upgrades or conversions to meet these standards. These Proposition 12-compliant facilities, though costly, command premiums in the market, making them one of the few viable capital expenditures in recent years.
Evolving Appraisal Factors in the Post-COVID Landscape
Beyond regulatory influences, the swine industry is also facing a dual economic challenge: an oversupply of market hogs and fluctuating feed costs. Despite increasing efficiency in pig production, stable or declining demand and market saturation have led to falling prices. Exports to Mexico and the European Union have shown some promise, offering a light at the end of the tunnel for producers.
Swine appraisals in this climate have also been shaped by efficiency gains in genetic advancements, feed conversion and facility technologies. Many of the older, less efficient facilities have been liquidated, which has indirectly boosted the market’s overall efficiency. Meanwhile, maintenance projects postponed during the lean years may return as profits slowly rebound.
Biosecurity and Regional Shifts
Biosecurity investments and strategic location choices are increasingly becoming a priority in appraisal considerations. Biosecurity has emerged as a crucial factor in farm appraisals. Recent outbreaks of diseases such as PRRS (Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome) and fears surrounding African Swine Fever have driven investment in biosecurity measures.
Farms are now built in less swine-dense areas to mitigate the risk of disease transmission, a trend that has influenced property values in historically dense swine regions like southern Minnesota and northern Iowa.
Looking Ahead: What Does the Future Hold?
Despite the hurdles, there are signs of recovery in the swine industry. Recent decreases in feed costs and slight increases in market prices have prompted cautious optimism among producers. As the industry slowly rebounds, producers are shifting from survival mode to considering long-postponed renovations and expansions.
With a unique ability to accurately appraise swine facilities, Compeer Financial brings critical expertise to help producers evaluate their assets and strategically plan for future investments. Whether you’re looking for a swine facility appraisal or agricultural financing, Compeer has the local experience and industry expertise to help your farm thrive.
Appraisal Services
Compeer Financial appraisal services specializes in the appraisal of farms and equipment.
Swine
If you are a pork producer, there’s no one better to have on your side than Compeer Financial. Small or large, our team works to help hog producers who want to expand or join the swine industry.